TrialsgrambetaRCTs are beautiful

Borderline personality disorder

DBT, MBT, schema-focused therapy, TFP and structured generalist management.

Trials
7
Years
1991–2009
Sort
  • 2009MBT vs SCM⁠Mentalisation-basedIn 134 patients with BPD, 18 months of outpatient MBT achieved fewer crisis events, self-harm episodes and hospitalisations than structured clinical management.Read →
  • 2009McMain GPM⁠Generalist managementIn 180 patients with BPD, 1 year of DBT achieved the same clinical improvement as structured general psychiatric management.Read →
  • 2007Clarkin TFP⁠Transference-focusedIn 90 patients with BPD, 1 year of TFP, DBT or supportive psychotherapy produced symptom improvement comparable across arms, with unique gains in reflective functioning under TFP.Read →
  • 2006DBT vs CTBE⁠Dialectical behaviour therapyIn 101 suicidal women with BPD, 1 year of DBT halved suicide attempts compared with community treatment by expert non-DBT therapists.HR 2.66Read →
  • 2006SFT vs TFP⁠Schema-focusedIn 88 patients with BPD, 3 years of schema-focused therapy produced higher recovery and lower dropout than transference-focused psychotherapy.RR 2.18Read →
  • 1999Bateman MBT⁠Mentalisation-basedIn 38 patients with BPD, 18 months of psychoanalytically-oriented day-hospital MBT reduced self-harm, hospitalisation and depressive symptoms compared with standard psychiatric care.Read →
  • 1991Linehan DBT Core⁠Dialectical behaviour therapyIn 44 chronically suicidal women with BPD, 1 year of dialectical behaviour therapy reduced parasuicidal behaviour and hospital days compared with treatment as usual.Read →