TrialsgrambetaRCTs are beautiful

Borderline personality disorder: recognition and management (NICE guideline CG78)

This guideline cites 5 of the 62 landmark trials in our Psychiatry & psychotherapy register.

Issued by
NICE
Year
2009
Source
National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. Borderline personality disorder: recognition and management. NICE guideline [CG78]. Published 28 January 2009; last reviewed 30 July 2024.

CG78 remains current guidance — NICE last reviewed it in July 2024 and left it in place — and its central claim has aged well: borderline personality disorder is treated psychotherapeutically, not pharmacologically. Drug treatment should not be used for the disorder itself or for its individual symptoms, and dialectical behaviour therapy is named for women with recurrent self-harm. The register trials below are grouped by therapeutic school; the two 2009 trials that appeared in December of that year could not have informed a guideline published in January and are listed separately.

Dialectical behaviour therapy2

  • 2006DBT vs CTBE⁠Psychiatry · BPD · Dialectical behaviour therapyIn 101 suicidal women with BPD, 1 year of DBT halved suicide attempts compared with community treatment by expert non-DBT therapists.HR 2.66Read →
  • 1991Linehan DBT Core⁠Psychiatry · BPD · Dialectical behaviour therapyIn 44 chronically suicidal women with BPD, 1 year of dialectical behaviour therapy reduced parasuicidal behaviour and hospital days compared with treatment as usual.Read →

Mentalisation-based treatment1

  • 1999Bateman MBT⁠Psychiatry · BPD · Mentalisation-basedIn 38 patients with BPD, 18 months of psychoanalytically-oriented day-hospital MBT reduced self-harm, hospitalisation and depressive symptoms compared with standard psychiatric care.Read →

Schema-focused & transference-focused psychotherapy2

  • 2007Clarkin TFP⁠Psychiatry · BPD · Transference-focusedIn 90 patients with BPD, 1 year of TFP, DBT or supportive psychotherapy produced symptom improvement comparable across arms, with unique gains in reflective functioning under TFP.Read →
  • 2006SFT vs TFP⁠Psychiatry · BPD · Schema-focusedIn 88 patients with BPD, 3 years of schema-focused therapy produced higher recovery and lower dropout than transference-focused psychotherapy.RR 2.18Read →

Published since the guideline2

  • 2009MBT vs SCM⁠Psychiatry · BPD · Mentalisation-basedIn 134 patients with BPD, 18 months of outpatient MBT achieved fewer crisis events, self-harm episodes and hospitalisations than structured clinical management.Read →
  • 2009McMain GPM⁠Psychiatry · BPD · Generalist managementIn 180 patients with BPD, 1 year of DBT achieved the same clinical improvement as structured general psychiatric management.Read →

Cited landmark trials not yet in the register4

Further landmark trials this guideline cites that are not (yet) covered in our register. Each links out to the study for further reading.

  • 2003Verheul DBT (Netherlands)

    DBT vs usual treatment in women with borderline personality disorder.

  • 2008Bateman & Fonagy 8-year follow-up

    Durable gains from partial hospitalisation MBT after eight years.

  • 2006BOSCOT

    Cognitive behaviour therapy added to usual treatment in BPD (UK).

  • 2008STEPPS

    Group systems training added to usual care in borderline personality disorder.

Every trial shown is one this guideline actually cites: each link was checked against the guideline's own reference list, and the few that a machine cannot match, a trial cited through a later follow-up, or a NICE guideline, which carries no DOI, were verified by hand against the full text. This is not the guideline's complete reference list, only the landmark trials it cites that our register holds.